A team of researchers from the United Kingdom recently conducted a comprehensive study to assess the effectiveness of existing intellectual property (IP) laws in relation to emerging technologies like the metaverse. The study revealed several shortcomings in current laws and presented recommendations for improvement.
On March 7, the U.K. government released a research report titled “IP and Metaverse,” which was commissioned externally. The report delved into the existing body of literature on IP laws and their relevance to the metaverse. Within the study, the researchers identified specific IP issues that arise in the metaverse, such as IP governance in an interoperable environment and the regulation of technologies like blockchain and artificial intelligence (AI) within virtual worlds.
One of the primary legal challenges associated with interoperability, according to the report, is the unauthorized dissemination of copyrighted works. The researchers emphasized that the lack of interoperability has played a crucial role in preventing the illegal distribution of copyrighted material. Given that interoperability is a fundamental aspect of the metaverse, the researchers believe that governing the use and circulation of copyrighted works could prove to be a challenge.
Moreover, the inherent characteristics of blockchain, such as immutability and tamper-proof nature, also present obstacles to enforcing IP laws. The researchers noted that these features of blockchain technology complicate the task of ensuring IP protection.
The use of AI in governing IP within the metaverse also poses anticipated challenges, as stated by the researchers. They argued that algorithmic management of IP infringements is highly susceptible to misuse due to the absence of human oversight, which is necessary to ensure the legitimacy of enforcement.
Furthermore, the study highlighted another challenge related to AI-generated content and IP enforcement in the metaverse. It pointed out that reliance on AI tools has the potential to invalidate claims of inventorship in content. The researchers cited examples and cases demonstrating that only works that are partially assisted by AI can be protected by IP laws.
Considering the projected issues in IP governance within the metaverse, the researchers concluded that there is a need for clarity on various key issues. This includes addressing legal matters concerning copyrights, trademarks, patents, designs, user-generated content, virtual property, and nonfungible tokens (NFTs) in the metaverse. Consequently, the researchers emphasized the necessity of formulating IP approaches to tackle governance and enforcement challenges in the metaverse.
In other news, Tony Pearce’s journey in time and space brings Doctor Who to Web3.